Why singing competitions are taking America by storm: The Susan Boyle effect and the reality show dream

12

The camera focuses on a 40-year-old woman. She had a shapeless champagne dress, but the silhouette didn’t change at all. Simon Cowell, the famously fierce judge on Britain’s Got Talent, grinned. He asked her to introduce herself.

“I’m Susan Boyle,” she said.

She wiggled her hips. The audience doesn’t just laugh. They laughed without hesitation. They await their collapse. Everyone thought they were about to witness an epic train wreck. Fair? That’s half the fun of the preliminary rounds of singing competitions. We can decide hopeless cases. Or place yourself in a star of the future, as if you found one in the basement.

But why is America so harsh on these programs? This isn’t just voyeurism. This is identification.

NPR’s The Record takes a closer look. What is the conclusion? The fans consider themselves hard workers. They look at the competitors on stage and think, “Maybe I can do it too.” *This is a prediction of potential. CMT’s Next Superstar producer Simon Lythgoe goes one step further. He believes that the story of penniless to millionaire is purely the story of the American Dream. In addition, the voting mechanism gives it a democratic feel. It feels like America.

Most of us have sung out loud in the shower. Or pretend you’re at the stadium and yell at your hairbrush. When we watch these shows, we’re not just watching other people. We imagine ourselves under bright lights. My heart is pounding. Think: * I am nothing to them anymore. But wait till they hear my song. *

Singing competitions may be the only reality show that guarantees stardom.

Let’s take a look at your resume. One Direction Harry, Niall, Louis, Liam and Zayn didn’t start in a garage. They started on The X Factor. Jennifer Hudson just didn’t get the part. After becoming famous on “American Idol”, he won an Oscar. Miranda Lambert won her fifth straight CMA Award for Female Vocalist of the Year after placing third with Nashville Star.

And then there’s Susan Boyle.

When he finally spoke, the script flipped. Simon Cowell took the jaw off. The audience laughed and stood up in unison. They applaud. they cried. They gave him a standing ovation. His debut album “I Dreamed a Dream” went to number one on the Billboard 200 and stayed there for six weeks.

We all dream of becoming a star. Our dream became stronger. Singing shows are popular because they open doors for extraordinary dreamers who are often overlooked. They show that talent doesn’t always mean wearing the right clothes.

But let’s be realistic. Even though Susan Boyle crashed and burned? It still makes me laugh. Regardless, the show still wins.